Key Takeaways

• Always work with a fiduciary advisor as they’re legally required to act in your best interest at all times.
• Seek transparency about all costs and how your advisor balances cost efficiency with value.
• Ensure your advisor has specific experience with executive compensation packages, tax strategies for high earners, and multi-million dollar portfolios.
• Look for structured accountability and behavioral coaching with a financial advisor.

If you live and work in New York City, you already know the financial scene is as crowded as the 6 train at rush hour. There’s no shortage of financial advisors here. Some sit in corner offices of global firms, armed with thick pitch books and an army of analysts. Others run boutique firms, meeting clients over coffee in Midtown or Zoom calls squeezed in between back-to-back board meetings.

In a city where everyone claims to be a financial guru, choosing the right wealth management professional can feel like finding a needle in a haystack.

The statistics are sobering; according to industry data, only about 33% of financial advisors in the United States hold CFP certification, the primary credential for comprehensive financial planning. Even fewer have significant experience working with high-net-worth clients.

In New York City specifically, the advisor landscape is particularly fragmented, with everyone from insurance agents to bank representatives calling themselves "wealth managers." The wrong choice doesn't just cost you money; it can derail decades of disciplined saving and careful planning.

So how do you separate the wheat from the chaff when interviewing potential financial advisors? The answer lies in knowing the right questions to ask financial advisor candidates. Not the softball inquiries that any advisor can answer with their eyes closed, but the probing questions that reveal their actual expertise, philosophy, and commitment to your financial well-being.

5 Questions to Ask When Interviewing a Financial Advisor

Let’s look at the top five questions every NYC professional should be asking before hiring a financial advisor, and more importantly, what the answers reveal.

‍

#1: "Are You a Fiduciary, and What Does That Mean for Our Relationship?"

Let's start with the big one. If you walk away from this article remembering only one thing, let it be this: always work with a fiduciary financial advisor. But here's where it gets interesting (and where many people get confused).

The term "financial advisor" is about as specific as calling someone a "business person". It's an umbrella term that covers everyone from insurance salespeople to registered investment advisors to wealth management professionals. Some of these professionals are bound by fiduciary duty, others are not.

A fiduciary is legally required to act in your best interest at all times. This isn't just a nice-to-have; it's a fundamental shift in how the relationship works. Non-fiduciary advisors operate under what's called the "suitability standard," which means they only need to recommend products that are suitable for you, not necessarily the best ones available.

Picture this scenario: you’re holding a stock that hasn’t moved much in the past year. A non-fiduciary advisor might suggest selling it and buying something else, not because it no longer fits your plan, but because each trade generates a commission for them. A fiduciary advisor, on the other hand, isn’t rewarded for creating activity in your account. Their job is to evaluate whether that stock still makes sense for your long-term strategy and only recommend changes that truly serve your best interest.

Many advisors can act as fiduciaries across different types of services — investment management, financial planning, and insurance recommendations. The key is ensuring they maintain that fiduciary standard consistently and have the independence to recommend the best solutions for your situation.

The follow-up question to ask: "How do you maintain your fiduciary duty across all the services you provide, and what gives you the independence to always recommend what's best for me?" Their answer will reveal both their commitment to your interests and their business model.

‍

#2: "How Do You Get Paid, and How Much Will This Cost Me?"

Money conversations can be awkward, but you didn't become a successful executive by avoiding uncomfortable topics. Understanding your advisor's compensation structure is crucial because it directly impacts the advice you receive.

There are three primary compensation models in wealth management, and each comes with its own set of trade-offs:

• ‍Fee-only advisors charge for their advice directly through hourly rates, flat fees, or asset-based fees (typically 0.5% to 1.5% of assets under management). Their compensation comes exclusively from advisory fees.‍

• Commission-based advisors earn money by selling financial products like mutual funds, insurance policies, or annuities. This model can work well when advisors prioritize finding the best solutions for clients, though transparency about compensation becomes crucial.

• Fee-based advisors combine both models, earning advisory fees for financial planning while also receiving commissions on certain products they recommend. The key advantage of this model — particularly with independent advisors — is flexibility. They can shop the entire market for insurance products, mortgages, and other financial solutions rather than being limited to proprietary products from a single firm.

What matters most isn't the compensation structure itself, but transparency about how your advisor is paid and whether they have the independence to recommend the best solutions for your situation, regardless of the source.

Here's what many executives don't realize: the total cost of working with an advisor extends beyond their direct fees. Investment costs, fund expenses, and transaction fees all impact your net returns. A quality advisor should be able to explain these costs and help you understand the value you're receiving relative to what you're paying.

Don't just ask about their fee structure; ask for transparency about the overall cost structure and their philosophy on balancing costs with value.

A good question to ask: "How do you approach balancing cost efficiency with getting the best solutions for my situation, and can you walk me through your typical cost structure?" This reveals both their transparency and their thinking process around value optimization.

‍

#3: "What's Your Investment Philosophy and Risk Management Approach?"

This question reveals the depth of an advisor's expertise and strategic thinking. A skilled wealth management professional should be able to articulate their investment philosophy clearly and explain how it applies to your specific situation.

But here's what you're really listening for: do they have a consistent, evidence-based approach, or are they chasing whatever investment strategy is currently fashionable? The financial services industry is notorious for trend-hopping, from dot-com stocks in the late '90s to real estate investment trusts before 2008 to the latest investment fads.

A knowledgeable advisor should discuss concepts like:

• Modern Portfolio Theory and diversification principles

• The role of asset allocation in determining long-term returns

• How they balance growth needs with capital preservation

• Their approach to tax-efficient investing (crucial for high earners like yourself)

• How they adjust strategies based on changing life circumstances

Pay attention to whether they're trying to impress you with complex strategies or if they're focused on fundamentally sound principles. As Warren Buffett once noted, "Risk comes from not knowing what you're doing." The same applies to your advisor.

Here's a follow-up question that reveals a lot about their sophistication: "How do you evaluate new financial instruments or market developments? What's your process for distinguishing between genuine innovation and speculative trends?" Their answer will tell you a lot about their understanding of academic research on investing and their analytical approach to evaluating opportunities.

For NYC executives with substantial taxable accounts, tax efficiency should be a central part of their investment philosophy. If they're not discussing tax-loss harvesting, asset location strategies, and the tax implications of different investment vehicles, they're not thinking comprehensively about your wealth.

‍

#4: "What's Your Experience Working with Clients in Situations Similar to Mine?"

This question serves multiple purposes. First, it helps you gauge whether the advisor has relevant experience with your specific challenges and opportunities. Second, it gives you insight into their typical client base and whether you'll be a good fit.

Managing wealth at your level involves unique challenges that mainstream financial advisors rarely encounter. You're dealing with complex compensation structures (stock options, restricted stock units, deferred compensation plans), alternative minimum tax calculations, estate planning considerations, and sophisticated tax strategies that simply don't apply to many investors.

An advisor who primarily works with middle-class families saving for retirement might be perfectly competent within their wheelhouse, but they could be out of their depth when working with executive compensation packages or multi-generational wealth transfer strategies.

Ask for specific examples: "Can you describe a situation where you helped a client similar to me

navigate [insert your specific challenge]?" Listen for concrete details and sophisticated understanding, not generic responses.

You should also inquire about their team structure. At your wealth level, you're not just hiring an

individual advisor; you're accessing their entire support system. Do they work with qualified tax

professionals? Do they have relationships with estate planning attorneys? Can they coordinate with your existing professional advisors?

Comprehensive wealth management in NYC for high-net-worth individuals requires a team approach.

Here's a sophisticated follow-up: "How do you coordinate with clients' existing tax advisors and estate planning attorneys?" Their answer should demonstrate experience working collaboratively with other professionals, not territorial behavior about being your only financial advisor.

‍

#5: “How Will You Measure Success in Our Relationship and Track Progress?”

This final question cuts to the heart of accountability and ongoing service. Many advisor relationships start strong but deteriorate over time due to poor communication and unclear expectations.

A professional advisor should have a structured approach to measuring and reporting on your progress. This goes beyond simple portfolio performance reports (though those are important). They should be tracking progress toward your specific goals, whether that’s accumulating enough wealth to retire comfortably, funding your child’s education, or building a legacy for future generations.

Here’s what sophisticated wealth management looks like: quarterly to semi-annual check-ins, annual comprehensive financial plan updates, and proactive communication about changes in tax laws, market conditions, or opportunities that affect your situation.

But there’s a deeper issue at play here. Many successful executives struggle with what psychologists call “wealth anxiety” — the persistent fear that they don’t have enough money despite substantial assets and high savings rates. A quality advisor should understand this dynamic and help you develop confidence in your financial security.

This phenomenon is particularly common among NYC finance professionals who see colleagues with even higher net worths or who constantly hear about market volatility and economic uncertainty. The irony is that many executives with $3-5 million in liquid assets still worry about running out of money, while simultaneously struggling to permit themselves to enjoy their wealth.

A sophisticated advisor recognizes this psychological component and helps clients develop what we call "spending confidence" — the ability to make discretionary purchases without guilt or anxiety when they're financially justified.

Ask them: “How do you help clients feel confident about their financial decisions and spending?” If they look at you blankly or give a generic response about diversification, they’re missing a crucial component of wealth management for high achievers.

The best advisors understand that their role extends beyond investment management. They serve as a behavioral coach, helping you make rational decisions during market volatility and giving you permission to enjoy the wealth you’ve accumulated when appropriate.

Bringing It All Together: How to Choose a Financial Advisor

Armed with these five questions, you're ready to make one of the most important professional decisions of your career.

You’re not just hiring someone to manage your investments. You are selecting a partner who will help guide complex financial decisions that could impact multiple generations of your family. The stakes are high, and the wrong choice can be expensive both financially and emotionally.

Consider creating a simple scorecard for each advisor you interview. Rate them on each of the five key areas we’ve discussed, and add any additional criteria that matter to your specific situation. This systematic approach helps remove emotion from the decision and ensures you’re making a choice based on substance rather than personality alone.

Remember, the most expensive advisor isn’t necessarily the best, but the cheapest option often costs more in the long run. Focus on finding someone who demonstrates competence, operates with integrity, and genuinely understands the unique challenges facing high-earning professionals.

The Bottom Line: Your Wealth Deserves Better Than Generic Advice

If you’ve made it this far, you’re clearly serious about making an informed decision about your financial future. That puts you ahead of most people, including many of your executive peers who simply go with whoever their colleague recommended without doing proper due diligence.

These five essential questions to ask financial advisor candidates are diagnostic tools designed to reveal whether a potential advisor has the expertise, integrity, and approach necessary to serve someone at your level effectively. Use them wisely, and don’t be afraid to ask follow-up questions when answers seem vague or unsatisfactory.

Your financial life is too complex and your goals too important to settle for anything less than excellence. The right financial advisor won’t just manage your money; they’ll help you sleep better at night knowing that your financial affairs are in capable, trustworthy hands.

At Servet Wealth Management, we specialize in helping high-earning professionals across the country navigate the complex intersection of wealth accumulation, tax optimization, and life planning.

To see if we can help you build confidence in your financial future while maximizing the efficiency of your wealth strategies, click here to schedule a conversation today. After all, your success deserves a financial partner who’s as committed to excellence as you are.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: How do I know if an advisor is the right fit for me?

A: Look for transparency, alignment with your values, and an approach that feels tailored to your life — not just your portfolio. The right advisor should make you feel confident in your decisions, not pressured.

‍

Q: Should I work with a large firm or a smaller independent advisor?

A: Both have advantages depending on your needs. The advisor’s individual competence matters more than firm size, but ensure they have the infrastructure to serve your wealth level effectively.

‍

Q: When should I consider switching financial advisors?

A: Consider switching if you experience poor communication, receive generic advice that doesn't fit your situation, or discover undisclosed conflicts of interest. Also, evaluate whether your wealth has outgrown their expertise, or if major life events (such as business sale, inheritance, or divorce) require specialized knowledge they lack.

‍